Response 877773438

Back to Response listing

About you

G. Do you consent to your response being published?

Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked Yes, with personal identifying information (name, organisation, respondent category, location, additional information - please note your email address will NOT be published if you choose this option)
Radio button: Ticked Yes, anonymised
Radio button: Unticked No

General

1. Do you have any general comments about our proposed new procedure?

Please provide your comments below
I am pleased to see that you are being given the power to review and amend airspace classification where appropriate, and that you will have the skills necessary to undertake airspace design. I hope you will use these new powers to strike a fair balance between the safety needs of both commercial and general aviation. It is particularly important that commercial aviation should only be allocated airspace that it really needs for safe operation substantiated by a safety case. Every allocation of airspace will lead to increased density of general aviation traffic and reduced safety in the remaining airspace. General aviation does not have the funds to propose airspace changes to counter commercial applications. I hope the CAA will use its new airspace design skills to develop fair compromise solutions where this is appropriate.

Consider stage

2. Do you have any comments about our proposed approach for the Consider stage?

Please select one item
Radio button: Unticked About right
Radio button: Ticked Some modifications needed
Radio button: Unticked Significant modifications
Radio button: Unticked Don't know

Consider - some modifications

Please provide your modifications below

modification comments
Rather than 'consider' reviewing, establish a routine of reviewing every two years.
As well as reviewing where 'we', the CAA considers a change might be made, add where 'others' consider a change might be made.

Review stage

3. Do you have any comments about our proposed approach for the Review stage?

Please select one item
Radio button: Unticked About right
Radio button: Ticked Some modifications needed
Radio button: Unticked Significant modifications needed
Radio button: Unticked Don't know

Review - some modifications

Please provide your modifications below

modification comments
Replace 'appropriate intelligence' with 'carry out an objective analysis of available data relating to all airspace users'.
Do not exclude recent design changes from consideration. First of all 'recent' is too vague a definition, more importantly, it may be that the internal design capability proposed for the CAA could improve some recently allocated airspace.

Amend stage

4. Do you have any comments about our proposed approach for the Amend stage?

Please select one item
Radio button: Unticked About right
Radio button: Ticked Some modifications needed
Radio button: Unticked Significant modifications needed
Radio button: Unticked Don't know

Amend - some modifications

Please provide your modifications below

modification comments
In the interest of transparency, provide the reasoning behind proposals being made.

Cost impacts

5. Please can you quantify the cost impacts of the new procedure on your organisation, or more broadly if possible, and how we might best minimise these?

Please provide your answer below
This response is not on behalf of an organisation.